How to Cook the Perfect Grass-Fed Steak
Published: // Updated:

How to Cook the Perfect Grass-Fed Steak

Let's talk about cooking grass-fed beef. If you've recently made the switch from conventional to grass-fed beef (congratulations, by the way!), you might have noticed it cooks a bit differently. That's because our cattle are raised the way nature intended: grazing on diverse pastures and living their best lives under the sun. The result? Incredibly nutrient-dense meat that deserves a slightly different approach in your kitchen.

Why Your Grass-Fed Steak Needs Special Treatment

Here's the thing about grass-fed beef: it's leaner and more nutrient-dense than its grain-fed counterpart. While that's fantastic for your health, it means we need to adjust our cooking methods to achieve that perfect, tender steak you're craving.

First, prep your steak.

  1. Pull your steak from the fridge about 30-40 minutes before cooking 
  2. Pat it dry with paper towels (moisture is the enemy of a good sear).
  3. Season well with quality sea salt and fresh-cracked pepper

Our Tried and True Method: The Cast Iron or Flat Top

  1. Heat your cast iron pan over medium heat. You want it hot, but not too hot. Once you see a little bit of smoke come off the top, then you're ready to add the tallow.
  2. Add a tbsp of Primal Patures Pure beef tallow to the cast iron and let it melt.
  3. Add your steak to the pan and leave it alone! One good press into hot oil to start, then cook for three minutes. Flip and repeat. 
  4. Cook until it reaches your preferred temperature (see below)

Temperature Guide (Because Timing is Everything):

    1. Rare: 120-125°F 
    2. Medium-rare: 130-135°F (our personal favorite)
    3. Medium: 140-145°F
    4. Medium-well: 150-155°F

Let it Rest (Don't skip this step!)

  1. Transfer to a rack or plate.
  2. Let it rest out for the same amount of time you cooked it. 3 minute sear on each side = 6 minutes of resting.
  3. Slice against the grain when you're ready to serve

Troubleshooting Tips:

  • Tough steak? You might be overcooking it – remember, grass-fed beef cooks faster. Could also be not letting your steak rest after cooking.
  • Chewy texture? Make sure you're slicing against the grain
  • Uneven cooking? Room temperature meat is your friend

Ready for the next level?

  • Experiment with compound butter (herbs + grass-fed butter = magic)
  • Play around with different seasoning blends (though sometimes, simple salt and pepper lets the beef shine)
See all articles in The Pasture Journal